One of the most common misconceptions among new Pygmy Goat fanciers is that a higher percentage automatically means a better goat. In reality, percentage only tells part of the story and is not a guarantee of quality.
An important distinction should be made from the outset. While a high percentage alone does not guarantee quality, achieving high percentages requires considerable time and financial investment, planning and dedication from breeders over many generations.
As a result, high-percentage Pygmy Goats are costly to produce and command substantial prices, regardless of individual quality.
However, percentage and quality are not the same thing. Quality breeding stock is the result of not only increasing Australian Pygmy Goat genetic percentage, but also consistently selecting for correct breed type, correct, sound conformation, desirable characteristics and the removal of breed faults.
This is why buyer education is so important.
Understanding how to evaluate quality Pygmy Goats for yourself, beyond percentage and price tag, helps ensure that the animal you purchase is genuinely worth the investment.
As with any animal, quality breeding stock is the result of years of planning, selection, time, significant money and trial and error. Buyers should therefore be cautious of assuming that a high price and percentage automatically guarantee quality or that quality, high percentage animals can be purchased cheaply.
Every established pet and livestock breeds including dogs, horses, cattle, sheep, alpacas and goats have, registered animals with documented pedigrees stretching back for generations.
Yet experienced, knowledgeable breeders understand that not every purebred or fullblood animal are of sufficient quality to be used for breeding.
A Pygmy Goat may be high-percentage, Purebred or Fullblood on paper, but that does not automatically make it a quality breeding animal. Likewise, at this stage of the breed’s development, a lower-percentage animal can still be a better representative of the breed than an animal with a higher percentage.
Registration Papers Do Not Guarantee Quality
Registration papers record written ancestry. They do not guarantee quality.
A pedigree cannot tell you whether an animal has:
- Correct breed type and character
- Sound structure and conformation
- Proper movement
- Desirable temperament
- Good reproductive performance
- Strong overall health
- The ability to consistently produce quality offspring
- Conformation faults
These traits must all be evaluated in the animal itself.
For example, if a 95% Pygmy Goat exhibits poor breed character, incorrect proportions, structural faults or undesirable traits, breeding from it simply because it is 95% does little to improve the breed and is likely to perpetuate those same issues in future generations.
On the other hand, an 85% Pygmy Goat that strongly reflects the breed standard, has no faults and consistently produces quality offspring may be a far more valuable animal for a breeding program.
The purpose of selective breeding in Australian Pygmy Goats is not simply to increase percentages. The goal is to produce animals in each successive generation that improve on both their parents and move closer to the ideal animal described in the Breed Standard.
The Price Trap
In Australia, Pygmy Goat percentage and price are closely linked. As percentages increase, so do sale prices. At the time of writing, prices for Pygmy Goats in the 90%+ range start around $4,000, while Fullblood animals may command prices of $7,000 to $10,000+.
Unfortunately, this can create a misleading assumption among newcomers to the breed that a higher purchase price automatically means a higher-quality animal.
While high-priced animals may be excellent representatives of the breed, price alone should never be used as a definitive measure of quality. A registration certificate, a high percentage and a substantial purchase price do not guarantee correct conformation, sound structure, breed character, reproductive performance or long-term breeding value.
As with any breed or species, buyers should evaluate the individual animal they are interested in, including its pedigree, its relatives and the breeder’s overall program and knowledge, rather than assuming that the most expensive animal is necessarily the best investment.
Understanding Percentage
There is no denying that percentages matter. In a grading-up breeding program, higher-percentage animals possess a greater proportion of Pygmy Goat genetics and therefore should exhibit the correct type and characteristics associated with the breed.
Low percentage animals, no matter how correct their conformation and type, have more non-Pygmy Goat genetics in their pedigree for their offspring to potentially throw back to.
Australian breeders seek to increase percentages over successive generations, which is the whole premise behind developing the breed. They should aim to use higher-percentage, true-to-type bucks in each successive generation while removing lower-percentage, less typey bucks from their breeding programs as quickly as possible.
It is my personal opinion that to move the Pygmy Goat breed forward, bucks under 80% should no longer be registered as breeding bucks.
We stand by this and have wethered all bucklings below 80%, irrespective of quality.
To date, the only association to implement a minimum percentage for registration of Pygmy Goat bucks is the AABMGS who require a minimum of 40% from 1 July 2026, progressing to a minimum of 50% from 1 July 2027.
Personally I would prefer to see this minimum set much higher, but it is a step in the right direction and I hope other associations follow suit without delay.
*The AGB Inc. requires full DNA parentage verification back to a known import and applies its own minimum imported-genetics percentages for registration. These requirements differ from those of other associations who register the majority of Pygmy Goats in Australia. DNA to Import is a different issue beyond the scope of this article.
That aside, percentage should be viewed as one tool in the selection process, not the sole measure of quality.
An animal can be genetically high-percentage or Fullblood and still possess faults that should not be perpetuated through breeding.
Conversely, a lower-percentage animal with fewer or less serious faults may exhibit superior breed type, conformation and overall quality, contributing positively to the breed’s development.
This variation in quality in the registered breeding population exists in every purebred or Fullblood animal breed, including Fullblood Pygmies in the USA and is not unique to Australian Pygmy Goats.
Bucks in particular should be outstanding examples of the breed and there should be no place in any breeding program for bucks with moderate, severe or disqualifying faults, irrespective of their percentage or pedigree.
The most successful breeding programs balance higher percentages (especially in bucks) with careful selection for desirable type and characteristics, correct conformation and the intentional removal of faults from their herds.
The Role of Inbreeding and Increasing Percentage
Another factor that new breeders should understand is that percentages can be increased through inbreeding, for example by mating a high-percentage or Fullblood sire to his daughter, or a son back to his dam.
This practice is not unique to Pygmy Goats and has been used throughout livestock and pet breed history to concentrate desirable traits and accelerate genetic progress.
In knowledgeable hands, linebreeding and carefully planned inbreeding can be valuable tools for establishing consistency and preserving desirable traits, provided they are combined with rigorous selection against faults.
However, inbreeding requires a thorough understanding of genetics, conformation, breed faults, inbreeding coefficients, as well as a willingness to remove undesirable progeny from the breeding population and ability to obtain outcrossed (unrelated) genetics for breeding the next generation.
While inbreeding can increase uniformity and fix desirable traits, it can also double up on undesirable traits, structural weaknesses, hidden genetic issues and over time result in inbreeding depression.
For this reason, responsible breeders carefully evaluate both animals before undertaking close-breeding programs. It is not something that should ever be recommended or attempted by inexperienced breeders.
The challenge is even greater within the Australian Pygmy Goat population. The vast majority of the Australian population ultimately traces back to a very small foundation group of Fullblood Pygmy Goats imported from the United States, which already has a high coefficient of inbreeding in its general population.
As a result, most animals in Australian pedigrees share common ancestors multiple times, particularly at higher percentages. This means the available gene pool among higher-percentage Pygmy Goats remains limited, with many animals sharing common ancestors repeatedly within their pedigrees.
Unfortunately, introducing less-related genetics is more challenging than simply sourcing animals from a different state, as most breeding programs across Australia still share common ancestors in recent generations.
Even after years of development, finding quality, genuinely unrelated breeding stock with low inbreeding coefficients can be extremely difficult. For responsible breeders, introducing new animals into a program while maintaining genetic diversity remains one of the biggest long-term challenges.
This does not mean inbreeding should never be used. It means that percentage increases achieved through close inbreeding can have undesirable consequences that may not be obvious as physical deformities.
Close inbreeding should only be undertaken by knowledgeable breeders who can accurately assess the animals involved.
Looking Beyond the Numbers
Experienced breeders evaluate far more than percentage when selecting breeding stock. They assess:
- Breed type and characteristics
- Conformation
- Structural correctness
- Breed faults and their degree of seriousness
- Health
- Temperament
- Reproductive performance
- Family consistency
- Pedigree analysis
- Genetic diversity
- Proven performance of relatives and offspring
Percentage is simply one piece of information. It tells you how much documented Pygmy ancestry an animal possesses. It does not tell you how well that animal represents the breed or how well it will perform in your herd as a breeding animal.
The most successful breeders of any animal species understand that genetic quality and breed quality are earned through careful selection over generations. They are not guaranteed by a number or name printed on a registration certificate.
Registration and percentage indicate ancestry (without DNA parentage verification, a registration certificate cannot actually prove the paper pedigree, but most associations accept the paper pedigree).
Quality on the other hand, is demonstrated by the animal standing in front of you.
The Importance of Breeder Education
For anyone considering the purchase of breeding stock, the single most valuable investment you can make is in your own education. This helps protect you from disappointment and expensive mistakes.
Take the time to study the Breed Standard and learn to recognise desirable breed characteristics, correct conformation and structure, and common breed faults.
Understanding what makes a correct Pygmy Goat will allow you to evaluate animals more objectively, regardless of their percentage, pedigree or purchase price.
While experienced breeders can offer guidance, developing your own knowledge will help you make informed decisions, ask better questions and select quality animals that genuinely contribute to your breeding goals.
The more familiar you become with the Breed Standard, breed faults and correct conformation, the less likely you are to be influenced by impressive percentages, long pedigrees or high price tags.
Questions Every Buyer Should Ask
- How does this animal compare to the Breed Standard?
- What faults or weaknesses does the breeder acknowledge in this animal?
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of its parents?
- What is the inbreeding coefficient?
- How closely related are the animals in the pedigree?
- Have the parents produced offspring that consistently resemble the Breed Standard?
- Has the animal or any of its close relatives produced any breed faults?
- Why was this particular mating planned?
- What are this animal’s strongest qualities as a breeding animal, and have those qualities been consistently passed on to offspring?
- What traits and characteristics is the breeder trying to improve?
Ethical, knowledgeable and responsible breeders who are not just breeding for the money, the pet market or for pretty colours welcome these types of questions.
In fact, the breeders who are making the most educated and conscientious selection decisions in their breeding programs are often the most willing to share their knowledge and discuss both strengths and weaknesses in their animals, what they are aiming to improve and what their future goals are.
They understand that in the end, informed and educated breeders make better breeding decisions, and better breeding decisions benefit the future of the breed as a whole, not just the goats in their own paddock.
©2025 Michelle Wrighton, Eagleburra Pygmy Goats. All rights reserved.
This article may not be reproduced, copied, distributed, republished or used in whole or in part without prior written permission from the copyright owner.